Subscribe Today

Get our best practices delivered straight to your inbox.

Beyond the like: building genuine community

February 27, 2025

Audience engagement isn’t just about catching attention—it’s about capturing hearts and minds. When people genuinely connect with a brand, platform, or mission, they do more than scroll past. They invest, think, and act.

For purpose-driven organizations, engagement is more than clicks and impressions. It’s about creating relationships that inspire action, fuel loyalty, and build community. Here’s how to make it happen.

The ROI of Purposeful Engagement

Engaging an audience goes far beyond racking up likes or shares. Real engagement happens when people feel valued and involved, leading to deeper connections and long-term investment.

Research backs this up: a 2018 study of 100,000+ customers found that people with an emotional connection to a brand spend twice as much as those who are just satisfied. These loyal supporters have a 306% higher lifetime value (LTV) and are 90% more likely to refer others.

In short, building real engagement isn’t just good for impact—it’s good for business.

Navigating Social Media’s Attention Overload

Social media is a great tool for expanding visibility and sparking engagement. And, it’s become an overcrowded space where attention spans are shorter than ever (seriously, one study claims shorter than a goldfish).

If audience engagement is a roaring fire, social media is the spark—but you need more than a spark to keep the fire burning. Quick likes and shares won’t sustain long-term connections. To create lasting engagement, craft a strategy blending social media with deeper relationship-building.

How to Make Social Media Work for You

  1. Encourage Next Steps: Use posts to guide followers toward action: sign-ups, RSVPs, or deeper engagement beyond the feed. 
  2. Leverage Direct Contact: Social is great for introductions, but email lists, events, and direct messages foster high-value connections.
  3. Use Built-in Tools: Polls, surveys, and interactive features give insights you can use for personalized content and better engagement.
  4. Mix It Up: Stories, live videos, and interactive posts keep content fresh and engaging while boosting visibility.

Building Engagement That Lasts

A great social strategy isn’t about chasing the algorithm but guiding followers toward deeper connections.

📩 Personalized Communication

  • Send personal emails: Segment lists by interest, offering updates and resources tailored to audience needs.
  • Custom surveys as a feedback loop: Asking the right questions shows you’re listening and builds more authentic relationships.
  • Conversational technology: Chatbots and interactive tools offer engaging 1-on-1 experiences beyond basic CTAs.

📊 Content Diversification

  • Mix up formats: Use in-depth guides, interactive challenges, or live Q&As to engage different types of supporters.
  • Exclusive mission-driven content: Share behind-the-scenes videos, impact stats, or supporter spotlights to deepen connection.

👥 Community-Building

  • Events & forums: Host Q&As, virtual gatherings, or discussions where people can connect with your team and each other.
  • Exclusive access: Reward super users with early content, behind-the-scenes looks, or personalized shoutouts.

Metrics That Matter

Measuring engagement isn’t just about counting likes—it also understanding which metrics really make the difference between likes and movements.

Open rates, survey responses, event RSVPs: these reveal real investment into your mission.
Feedback loops: supporters willing to share insights into their experiences can help shape content and ongoing conversation.

📌 Pro Tip: Use email tags, feedback scores (CSAT, NPS), and audience insights to tailor engagement strategies.

Authentic Engagement = Lasting Relationships

Real engagement isn’t about vanity metrics—it’s about listening, responding, and creating spaces where people feel valued. By focusing on deeper conversations and meaningful interactions, you’ll cultivate an audience that’s engaged and invested in your mission.

Ready to build a community that sticks around? Let’s make it happen. 🚀

Julie Sandler

Managing Director, Growth & Marketing

More From The Chat Bubble

Survey Design 101: avoid bias and get better responses

Julie Sandler
-
5
min read

Great surveys don’t happen by accident—ditch the bias, get better responses, and design surveys that actually work!

Read On

Are your political views really yours?

Jake Sandler
-
2
min read

The surprising reason you agree with your political party (more than you think).

Read On