Ever found yourself raving about a book just because your friends loved it—when, deep down, you didn’t? Or kept eating at a restaurant you’re not crazy about because it’s your family’s go-to? Welcome to being human—where our brains nudge us to follow the group, sometimes at the expense of what we actually want.

We like to think we make independent choices, but group influence is powerful. This “follow the crowd” instinct doesn’t just affect our social lives—it plays a big role in politics, too. If our party backs a stance, we’re more likely to agree—even when it contradicts our personal views.

Why We Follow the Party Line

This isn’t just a hunch; it’s backed by research. Psychologist Geoffrey L. Cohen found that people’s attitudes toward policies often depend more on who endorses them than on the actual details. In multiple studies, participants reshaped their opinions to align with their political party—even when it meant flipping their stance on an issue.

The Brain Loves Shortcuts

So why do we let party loyalty override personal beliefs? Belonging. Our brains are wired to seek out groups that make us feel safe, and political parties serve as a home base for navigating complex issues.

Instead of digging into the fine print of every policy, we lean on our party’s stance as a mental shortcut. If it feels like “home,” it must be right—so our brain adjusts our reasoning to match.

How Party Loyalty Shapes Our Views

Imagine two versions of a healthcare policy: one offering generous benefits and another with stricter limitations.

• A conservative might instinctively prefer the stricter plan—unless their party backs the generous one. Their brain quickly reframes it: "Maybe this helps people help themselves in the long run."
  
  
• A liberal might favor expanded benefits—until their party supports a tougher stance. Suddenly, they see it as promoting fairness and sustainability.
  
  

This mental shape-shifting happens without us realizing it. We don’t think we’re following the party—we believe we’re making independent, fact-based decisions.

Think You’re Immune? Think Again.

Here’s where it gets interesting: even though most of us are influenced by party loyalty, we rarely see it in ourselves.

This is called the “bias blind spot”—the idea that others are swayed by group influence, but we’re just being logical. In Cohen’s study, participants denied that party affiliation shaped their views, even when it clearly did.

Breaking Free from Party-First Thinking

So how do we make sure our opinions are truly ours?

👀 Check your gut reaction: when a new policy pops up, take a beat. Would you feel the same if the opposite party supported it?

📖 Read beyond the headlines: strip away the endorsements and evaluate policies on their merit.

🤝 Look for common ground: sometimes, a good idea is a good idea—regardless of which party backs it.

The Bottom Line

Our brains crave community, and that’s okay. In a world of hot takes and party-first politics, a little independent thinking goes a long way. By putting policy before party, we can stay true to our values, challenge assumptions, and maybe—just maybe—bridge a few divides along the way.

‍